I have reviewed the article entitled “Money and Motivation.” In this Harvard Educational article, journalist David McKay Wilson reports on rewards and student achievement. Kids across America are being paid a lot of money. Middle-school students in Washington D.C. can get as much as 1,500 per year for high grades, good attendance, wearing their school uniform everyday, and for having exceptional behavior. In Chicago, ninth and tenth graders can earn up $200 every five weeks. If you fail one class, you loose all of your earnings for that grading period. If you do well in all of your classes, you can earn up to $2,000. Half is payable at the end of the year—but to collect the other half, you have to stay in school until graduation.
Even though these concerns are being viewed by research grants from private corporate foundations, Arne Duncan, former CEO of the Chicago Public Schools who in January became the U.S. Secretary of Education, believes the dropout problem is urgent enough to justify more experimentation with monetary rewards. In Chicago, Duncan says, he was “fighting for the lives” of inner-city teens, who need high school diplomas to gain a foothold in the local workforce. “If they stay in school, it shapes the rest of their lives,” he says. “It’s make-or-break time. We need to keep them engaged.”
What are your views?
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

We must keep in mind that money can be the "root of all evil". What about the kids who consistently discipline themselves to do their very best in school? Perhaps they don't attend one of the schools that subsidizes good grades? Is that fair to the child? Are we putting our students in competition with each other? What ever happened to believing in one's self and doing one's very best because we deserve the very best for ourselves and the world we live in? As educators we must instill a sense of "hope" in our children. Money is never the "end all - be all". And in this case, the green stuff might even set our kiddoes up for failure.
ReplyDeleteI don't like the idea. What is happening to the intrinsic motivation that kids used to possess. When I first read an article on that topic, I was appalled and a bit angered. I still feel the same way. What is the world coming to?
ReplyDeletejeri had a similar post a few weeks ago, check it out, i see some difference of opinion. i don't like it either. i'm not naive to think that it wouldn't work or that we need something more than just what we hope will work, but i'm sticking to my proverbial guns on this one.
ReplyDeleteWhat about Dylan Wiliam's research showing that for every kid that stays in school, society saves $209,000? ($139,000 in extra tax revenue, $40,500 savings in public health care cost, $26,600 savings in law enforcement costs, $3,000 welfare savings)Yes, I too believe in the intrinsic value of wanting to learn to better yourself, but for kids who have no one to model this for them, why not offer them something (like an allowance) that motivates them in a language which has meaning to them now? Once we've got them hooked into learning, then let's see how the intrincic values drive them forward. Of course, this all hinges on engaged learning that feeds the passion to want to learn more.
ReplyDelete